diff --git a/Modules/Linksehat/Http/Controllers/Api/Doctor/ChatDoctorController.php b/Modules/Linksehat/Http/Controllers/Api/Doctor/ChatDoctorController.php
index 4e39f144..1809f0ac 100644
--- a/Modules/Linksehat/Http/Controllers/Api/Doctor/ChatDoctorController.php
+++ b/Modules/Linksehat/Http/Controllers/Api/Doctor/ChatDoctorController.php
@@ -62,8 +62,12 @@ class ChatDoctorController extends Controller
                 $lastMessage = Message::where('channel_id', $d['id'])
                                 ->latest('created_at')
                                 ->first();
-                $urlAvatarDefault = $user->detail->nIDJenisKelamin == 1 ? 'https://linksehat.dev/assets/img/users/male-avatar.png' : 'https://linksehat.dev/assets/img/users/female-avatar.png';
-                $avatarMember = $user->detail->sImage ?? $urlAvatarDefault;
+                if ($user->detail){
+                    $urlAvatarDefault = $user->detail->nIDJenisKelamin == 1 ? 'https://linksehat.dev/assets/img/users/male-avatar.png' : 'https://linksehat.dev/assets/img/users/female-avatar.png';
+                    $avatarMember = $user->detail->sImage ?? $urlAvatarDefault;
+                } else {
+                    $avatarMember = 'https://linksehat.dev/assets/img/users/male-avatar.png';
+                }
                 
                 $arr['id'] = $d['id']; 
                 $arr['avatar'] = $avatarMember;