diff --git a/Modules/Internal/Http/Controllers/Api/LivechatController.php b/Modules/Internal/Http/Controllers/Api/LivechatController.php
index 2f71ede3..39b1379f 100644
--- a/Modules/Internal/Http/Controllers/Api/LivechatController.php
+++ b/Modules/Internal/Http/Controllers/Api/LivechatController.php
@@ -64,8 +64,8 @@ class LivechatController extends Controller
 
         $liveChats = Livechat::with('user:nID,sFirstName,sLastName,sEmail,sPhone', 'doctor:nID,nIDSpesialis,nIDUser', 'doctor.user:nID,sFirstName,sLastName', 'appointment:nID,sPaymentStatus', 'appointment.appointmentDetail:nID,nIDAppointment,dTanggalAppointment,tTimeAppointment', 'healthCare:nID,sHealthCare')
             ->where(function (Builder $query) use ($startDate, $endDate) {
-                $query->where('nIDAppointment', '!=', null);
-                $query->where('nIDAppointment', '!=', '');
+                // $query->where('nIDAppointment', '!=', null);
+                // $query->where('nIDAppointment', '!=', '');
                 if ($startDate) {
                     $query->where('dCreateOn', '>=', $startDate);
                 }