diff --git a/Modules/Internal/Http/Controllers/Api/CorporateMemberController.php b/Modules/Internal/Http/Controllers/Api/CorporateMemberController.php
index 52c82bee..af371c36 100755
--- a/Modules/Internal/Http/Controllers/Api/CorporateMemberController.php
+++ b/Modules/Internal/Http/Controllers/Api/CorporateMemberController.php
@@ -240,7 +240,7 @@ class CorporateMemberController extends Controller
                     'currentPolicy', 
                     'currentPlan.corporateBenefits' => function ($benefit) use ($request) {
                         return $benefit->when($request->benefit_ids, function ($q, $ids) {
-                            return $q->whereIn('id', $ids);
+                            return $q->whereIn('benefit_id', $ids);
                         });
                     }, 
                     'currentPlan.corporateBenefits.benefit']);
diff --git a/frontend/dashboard/src/pages/Report/Appointments/List.tsx b/frontend/dashboard/src/pages/Report/Appointments/List.tsx
index e6a5c5b5..bb6868f6 100644
--- a/frontend/dashboard/src/pages/Report/Appointments/List.tsx
+++ b/frontend/dashboard/src/pages/Report/Appointments/List.tsx
@@ -212,10 +212,10 @@ export default function List() {
                   <Grid item xs={2}>Metode Pembayaran</Grid><Grid item xs="10">: {row.payment_method}</Grid>
                   <Grid item xs={2}>HIS RegID</Grid><Grid item xs="10">: {row.his_detail?.sRegID}</Grid>
                   <Grid item xs={2}>HIS Medrec</Grid><Grid item xs="10">: {row.his_detail?.Medrec}</Grid>
-                  <Grid item xs={2}>No HP</Grid><Grid item xs="10">: {row.patient.sPhone ?? ''}</Grid>
-                  <Grid item xs={2}>E-mail</Grid><Grid item xs="10">: {row.patient.sEmail ?? ''}</Grid>
-                  <Grid item xs={2}>Alamat</Grid><Grid item xs="10">: {row.patient.detail.sAlamat ?? ''}</Grid>
-                  <Grid item xs={2}>KTP</Grid><Grid item xs="10">: {row.patient.detail.sKTP ?? ''}</Grid>
+                  <Grid item xs={2}>No HP</Grid><Grid item xs="10">: {row.patient?.sPhone ?? ''}</Grid>
+                  <Grid item xs={2}>E-mail</Grid><Grid item xs="10">: {row.patient?.sEmail ?? ''}</Grid>
+                  <Grid item xs={2}>Alamat</Grid><Grid item xs="10">: {row.patient?.detail?.sAlamat ?? ''}</Grid>
+                  <Grid item xs={2}>KTP</Grid><Grid item xs="10">: {row.patient?.detail?.sKTP ?? ''}</Grid>
                 </Grid>
               </Stack>  
             </Collapse>