diff --git a/app/Services/ClaimService.php b/app/Services/ClaimService.php
index d132add8..d5ecced8 100644
--- a/app/Services/ClaimService.php
+++ b/app/Services/ClaimService.php
@@ -112,7 +112,7 @@ class ClaimService{
         // $policy = $member->currentPolicy;
         // $corporate = $member->currentCorporate;
         $benefit = $member->currentPlan->benefits()->where('code', $benefit_code)->first();
-        $corporateBenefit = $member->currentPlan->corporateBenefits()->where('benefit_id', $benefit->id)->active()->first();
+        $corporateBenefit = $member->currentPlan->corporateBenefits()->where('benefit_id', $benefit->id ?? null)->where('plan_id', $member->currentPlan->id)->active()->first();
 
         // dd($benefit->toArray());
         // dd(compact(['plan', 'policy', 'corporate', 'benefit']));