diff --git a/Modules/Internal/Services/CorporateService.php b/Modules/Internal/Services/CorporateService.php
index 497cbd15..11444721 100755
--- a/Modules/Internal/Services/CorporateService.php
+++ b/Modules/Internal/Services/CorporateService.php
@@ -245,14 +245,13 @@ class CorporateService
                             ->where('corporate_plan_id', $benefit_data['plan_code'])
                             ->first();
             $benefit_data['plan_code'] = $plan->id;
-            $benefit = Benefit::updateOrCreate([
+            $benefit = Benefit::firstOrCreate([
                 'code' => $benefit_data['code'],
                 'service_code' => $plan->service_code,
             ], [
-                'code' => $benefit_data['code'],
-                'service_code' => $plan->service_code,
-                'description' => $benefit_data['description'],
+                'description' => $benefit_data['description'], // hanya initial
             ]);
+
             $corporateBenefit = $corporate->corporateBenefits()->updateOrCreate([
                 'benefit_id' => $benefit->id,
                 'plan_id' => $plan->id,