diff --git a/app/Services/ClaimRequestService.php b/app/Services/ClaimRequestService.php
index 78105beb..4ddb237b 100644
--- a/app/Services/ClaimRequestService.php
+++ b/app/Services/ClaimRequestService.php
@@ -69,20 +69,21 @@ class ClaimRequestService{
             ];
 
             $claimRequest = ClaimRequest::updateOrCreate(['request_log_id' => $requestLogID],$claimRequestData);
-            $benefitData = Benefit::where('code', $row['benefit_code'])->first();
-            $requestLogData = RequestLogBenefit::updateOrCreate(
-            [
-                'request_log_id' => $requestLogID,
-                'benefit_id' => $benefitData->id,
-            ],[
-                'request_log_id' => $requestLogID,
-                'benefit_id' => $benefitData->id,
-                'amount_incurred' => $row['amount_incurred'],
-                'amount_approved' => $row['amount_apporve'],
-                'amount_not_approved' => $row['amount_not_apporve'],
-                'excess_paid' => $row['excess_paid'],
-            ]);
-            
+            if (count($row)>0){
+                $benefitData = Benefit::where('code', $row['benefit_code'])->first();
+                $requestLogData = RequestLogBenefit::updateOrCreate(
+                [
+                    'request_log_id' => $requestLogID,
+                    'benefit_id' => $benefitData->id,
+                ],[
+                    'request_log_id' => $requestLogID,
+                    'benefit_id' => $benefitData->id,
+                    'amount_incurred' => $row['amount_incurred'],
+                    'amount_approved' => $row['amount_apporve'],
+                    'amount_not_approved' => $row['amount_not_apporve'],
+                    'excess_paid' => $row['excess_paid'],
+                ]);
+            }
             DB::commit();
 
             return $claimRequest;